The Creation Spirituality Lineage Calling All Social and Environmental Activists, Mystic Explorers, Justice Makers, Cosmic Thinkers, Earth Keepers Daily Meditations with Matthew Fox |
Sustainability as a New
Word By Gianluigi Gugliermetto 12/18/2025 |
Last week, I dropped a sentence about “sustainability,” which sparked a conversation. I wrote that “Sustainability, in reality, is not about bringing back a substantial balance — as we would like to believe — but it’s simply about reducing the damage we do” (see DM Dec.13). Then Matthew sent me an email in which he said the following: |
“Sustainability” is a very important word for the 21st century; it is a new word — we might say — for justice and balance and homeostasis. It is found in our bodies, in our minds (“all dreams come for healing,” says Jeremy Taylor), in societies that survive, and |
|
in our relationship to nature if we are to survive with it. How can one not appreciate Matthew Fox’s definition and the wealth of deep thought that lies behind it? So what did I mean? Sustainability is a word that did not exist when I was in high school. It was introduced by the U.N. Brundtland Commission in 1983, which also provided the concept of “sustainable development” in 1987. Since then, both have known a great favor. As it happens with all expressions that become fashionable, their meaning and their uses have varied a lot in the last forty years. Today, there is a wide scholarly output not just on sustainability, but on what people mean when they talk about it. Years ago, a friend who worked professionally as a philosopher in the field of “sustainable studies” told me that she wanted to quit because the field itself was becoming too
confusing!
|
A forest of Daisugi (coppiced) trees: a centuries-old Japanese technique of sustainably harvesting wood without depleting the forest ecosystem. Wikimedia Commons | Upon research, I learned that the word “sustainability”
existed since 1713 in the German language as Nachhaltigkeit — still the German word for sustainability — as applied to forestry. It meant that if you want to cut trees in a forest for human use, you ought to do it in a way that the |
forest does not die, but keeps healthy and grows enough new trees for the use of the next generations. Forestry studies have, of course, expanded enormously since then, but this is not a bad pedigree for our word, it turns out! The problem with “sustainability” does not reside, therefore, in the
concept itself, which is instead quite noble. It expands the mind beyond the confines of the modern era of greed and anthropocentrism. It speaks about justice and balance — as Matthew says — in a way that includes bodily creatures: minerals, plants, trees, animals, and our own animal bodies. It defines in a new and accessible way the great old word homeostasis, which may sound difficult outside the circles of philosophically-minded people. |
But there are problems with the use of the word and its related expressions. The most obvious problem is greenwashing: companies fill their mouths and their ads with sustainability, but it’s a lie that helps them raise their profits. This might be hard to spot by non-experts like myself, but it is a clearly defined issue. |
An environmental video essay taking a critical look at greenwashing, using Fiji Water’s deceptive marketing campaign as a case study. Our Changing Climate |
A much more complicated issue is the distinction between weak and hard sustainability. In the first model, technology will be able to help nature recover from the damages inflicted by humans; in the second model, such trust in technology is ill-placed: while nature is able in some cases to recover by itself in suprising ways, we humans should be aware that certain functions provided by nature, once lost, cannot be recovered at all by technological means. A major development in the use of the word has been represented by focusing on three distinct yet intertwined aspects of sustainability: ecological, economic, and social. These are included in the U.N. sustainability goals. Critics of this development underline that the ecological dimension should always be understood as the overarching dimension — both logically and practically — and not as just one of the three. |
The "wedding cake model" for sustainable development goals, where the environmental dimension is the basis for the other two dimensions (click the image to increase its size). Stockholm Resilience Centre, Stockholm University. Wikimedia Commons. | Indeed, it seems to me that even the honest uses of the word “sustainability” risk producing zero results, unless it is clear that the human economy at present is eating up the natural resources and altering the cycles of life on earth. Slowing down such processes is not enough at all. |
The elephant in the room that few want to see is this: continued economic growth is not compatible with the life of biological organisms — including humans. The capitalistic economic model has been successful in the short run, but it’s suicidal in the long run. A deep reflection on sustainability should issue in a deep critique of the present triumphant economic model. Unfortunately, when one digs a bit into the current uses of the word “sustainability” in political documents or the policies of big companies, more often than not, one finds that almost nobody takes seriously the idea of balance, which is at the root of the word itself. In most cases, what is truly meant by sustainability is “damage reduction,” which is not bad, but it is not truly honest either. Perhaps we as spiritual people have a job specially tailored for us. Just as Matthew did in his email to me, our job is that of reminding ourselves and others of the root-meaning of the word “sustainability” and its nobility, while noticing and studying its uses and abuses. |
Banner Image: "It Ain't Much, But It's Honest Work." American farmer David Brandt, known for using, improving, and advocating for sustainable agriculture techniques, specifically no-till farming and cover crops. Outside of the agriculture field, he was known on the internet for being the face of the "Honest Work" meme. Wikimedia Commons. |
Queries for Contemplation Are you familiar with the debates on sustainability? Do you find this to be a
spiritual matter worthy of your time? |
Responses are welcomed. To add your comment, or read other comments and enter into dialogue, please click HERE to go to our website and scroll down to the Comments field. |
|
| Counterpoint: A Response to Peter Thiel’s Antichrist An Important Conversation with Matthew Fox and Gil Duran Did you miss this two-session series with its powerful counter-narrative rooted in wisdom, justice, and |
authentic spirituality? This is your
chance to add it to your library of classics to be watched, re-watched, and contemplated. Fox explores the archetype of Christ and Antichrist as it plays out in our world today but also in artists of old. He draws from the teachings of Jesus and Hildegard of Bingen, Meister Eckhart, Carl Jung, and other mystics and visionaries, illuminating the stark contrast between life-giving and life-destroying spiritual energies. Purchase HERE. |
UPCOMING EVENTS See Matthew Fox's full calendar HERE |
Join Matthew Fox in a free 4-session Online Lecture/Discussion/Q&A event, “Creation Spirituality and the Celebrating & Healing of Mother Earth & Ourselves,” co-presented by the Episcopal Diocese of Wisconsin and Matthew Fox Legacy Project. Wednesdays, January 14, 21,28, February 4, 2026, 4:00pm-5:30pm
PT January 14 - Creation as an Original Blessing and the Springboard of Awe and Wonder January 21 - Sacred Mother Earth: The Holiness of Creation and Recovering the Cosmic Christ January 28 - The Cosmic Mass, and the Stations of the Cosmic Christ: Reinvigorating Liturgy and Rituals February 4 - Jesus as a Teacher of Democracy and the Renewal of Education and Values through the “10 Cs” Register HERE |
MONTHLY: Join Matthew Fox and Skylar Wilson of the Order of the Sacred Earth in a free virtual meeting for connection and networking with other mystic warriors. Last Tuesday of every month, 4:00-5:00pm PT.
Join Zoom Meeting HERE, Meeting ID: 886 6530 2478 Learn more at www.orderofthesacredearth.org |
Awakening the Divine Human: An Immersion in the Living Wisdom of Creation Spirituality …a week-long retreat in Sardinia, Italy, May 25-30, 2026 Join us on the sacred
island of Sardinia for a deeply immersive 6-day retreat rooted in the teachings of Matthew Fox, C.G. Jung, and the ancient wisdom of the land. Set along the turquoise shores and among the Neolithic sites of this timeless Mediterranean island, this retreat invites you into a transformative journey of reconnection—with Earth, Self, Gender, and the Divine. Learn more HERE. |
Creation Spirituality Conversations |
Join Matthew Fox for a transformative 4-part series that brings together some of the most provocative spiritual leaders, thinkers, and activists of our time. Together, we’ll explore the deep spiritual roots of this political moment and uncover pathways toward
collective action, resilience, and renewal. Learn more HERE. |
|
|
Inspired by this post? Share your insights on BlueSky, Instagram, Universeodon, or Facebook using the hashtag #RevDrMatthewFox and tag Matt with @RevDrMatthewFox FOLLOW MATTHEW FOX: |
|
|
|
